Seymour Almasy
New member
- Joined
- Oct 11, 2004
- Messages
- 93
- Points
- 0
Ace Andrews vs Jay Connor: Le double no-show. LET THE BIG SAUCE MAN GO ON. I'LL EVEN RP FOR HIM!
'Jester' Chad Allen vs Tarrasque: I've seen far, FAR worse than Tarrasque content wise in my eW tenure, so it didn't bother me that much. This RP battle would have fit in the IWO perfectly, so it made me smile a lot while reading it. Tarrasque by a nose.
Jeff Andrews vs Dr. Curiosity: One RP all, this is close, the second from Andrews eliminated Herr Doctor. I'd be happier if I didn't think gideon wins in Bracket Two and could still do insane damage in this thing.
Justin Voss vs Mark Maverick: Voss and Maverick did some good work here, but I think Voss was better enough to take this on. The Big Voss Man to move on here.
'Arrogance' Joey Melton vs Ethan Archer (j): Mr. Lindsay Troy and one of David Walter Smith's least favorite people ever moves along over El Jobbo.
Kin Hiroshi vs 'The Dream' Marcus Davis: Tough RP battle here, and when I'm stuck, I pick my favorite RP as the decider. Muffin Man's first was my favorite of the lot, so Kin Hiroshi to move on.
'Daddy' Jared Wells vs Showtime: Showtime here, I liked the story told and the way he went about his two pieces.
AJ Johnson vs Jace Gryphon: Toss up! I like Jace a tiny bit better though, overall, over the two RPs.
Zero vs Blaine Hollywood: Blaine Hollywood, who did what he wanted to do, IMO, better than Zero did what he wanted to do. Simple as that for my judging two cents.
Dom Jacobs vs El Gordo Grande: THE BIG FAT to move along in this one. Comedy done well can be dangerous, and the character is rock-solid, with the handler able to write him well.
Cobra vs 'The Egobuster' Dan Ryan: Loooooot of ink spilled on this one, and I'm in the pro-Cobra camp in spite of a great GREAT first roleplay from the Ego Buster.
El Lobo Loco (j) vs Spike Saunders: Saunders
The Big Sauce Man (j) vs Sylo: Sylo, in spite of being against the Best Jobber Ever.
Umpiro vs Troy Douglas: Douglas wins here because he had two good RPs while Umpiro had one good RP and one experimental RP that didn't really get there. Douglas is a solid, solid writer to boot.
'Gentlemen' Jonathan Marx vs King Krusher: RPs are similar length, similar quality. I honestly have no idea how to judge this, so I'm glad I'm not. I take KK because "AND THAT SUCKS FOR YOU!" is an awesome/awful/awesome again RP ender.
'Crippler' Cameron Cruise vs Ikan Jobtayoo (j) Triple C moves along.
'Jester' Chad Allen vs Tarrasque: I've seen far, FAR worse than Tarrasque content wise in my eW tenure, so it didn't bother me that much. This RP battle would have fit in the IWO perfectly, so it made me smile a lot while reading it. Tarrasque by a nose.
Jeff Andrews vs Dr. Curiosity: One RP all, this is close, the second from Andrews eliminated Herr Doctor. I'd be happier if I didn't think gideon wins in Bracket Two and could still do insane damage in this thing.
Justin Voss vs Mark Maverick: Voss and Maverick did some good work here, but I think Voss was better enough to take this on. The Big Voss Man to move on here.
'Arrogance' Joey Melton vs Ethan Archer (j): Mr. Lindsay Troy and one of David Walter Smith's least favorite people ever moves along over El Jobbo.
Kin Hiroshi vs 'The Dream' Marcus Davis: Tough RP battle here, and when I'm stuck, I pick my favorite RP as the decider. Muffin Man's first was my favorite of the lot, so Kin Hiroshi to move on.
'Daddy' Jared Wells vs Showtime: Showtime here, I liked the story told and the way he went about his two pieces.
AJ Johnson vs Jace Gryphon: Toss up! I like Jace a tiny bit better though, overall, over the two RPs.
Zero vs Blaine Hollywood: Blaine Hollywood, who did what he wanted to do, IMO, better than Zero did what he wanted to do. Simple as that for my judging two cents.
Dom Jacobs vs El Gordo Grande: THE BIG FAT to move along in this one. Comedy done well can be dangerous, and the character is rock-solid, with the handler able to write him well.
Cobra vs 'The Egobuster' Dan Ryan: Loooooot of ink spilled on this one, and I'm in the pro-Cobra camp in spite of a great GREAT first roleplay from the Ego Buster.
El Lobo Loco (j) vs Spike Saunders: Saunders
The Big Sauce Man (j) vs Sylo: Sylo, in spite of being against the Best Jobber Ever.
Umpiro vs Troy Douglas: Douglas wins here because he had two good RPs while Umpiro had one good RP and one experimental RP that didn't really get there. Douglas is a solid, solid writer to boot.
'Gentlemen' Jonathan Marx vs King Krusher: RPs are similar length, similar quality. I honestly have no idea how to judge this, so I'm glad I'm not. I take KK because "AND THAT SUCKS FOR YOU!" is an awesome/awful/awesome again RP ender.
'Crippler' Cameron Cruise vs Ikan Jobtayoo (j) Triple C moves along.